6. Circuit Breaker Sizing

Principle: Sizing a circuit breaker (or fuse/overcurrent protective device) involves determining the appropriate current rating for normal operation and ensuring the device can interrupt fault currents. The breaker must be chosen to carry the load safely (without nuisance tripping) and to trip quickly under overload or short-circuit conditions before damage occurs.

There are two primary aspects:

  • Thermal/Overload Sizing: The breaker's continuous current rating (In) should be at or above the circuit's design current (Ib) but not so high as to leave the circuit unprotected. Typically, Ib ≤ In ≤ Iz, where Iz is the cable’s continuous capacity. This ensures the breaker will carry the load but trip if current exceeds cable capacity.
  • Short-Circuit/Interrupting Rating: The breaker's interrupting capacity (IC or AIC in kA) must exceed the maximum prospective fault current at its installation point. If the fault current is higher than what the breaker can handle, it could fail to clear the fault, which is dangerous. In some cases, a series combination (backup protection) is used, but generally each device must stand alone at its location.

Overload Sizing Guidelines

Standards give rules of thumb. For instance, in BS 7671 (UK): Design Current (Ib) ≤ Device Rating (In) ≤ Cable Capacity (Iz). For example, if a circuit draws Ib = 22 A, one might choose a 25 A breaker (In = 25 A) and ensure the cable can handle at least 25 A (with an Iz of, say, 30 A to provide margin). The device's time-current curve should protect the cable from overheating – often checked by ensuring I2 ≤ 1.45 Iz (where I2 is the current that causes the breaker to trip in a specified time, e.g., 1 hour).

In the NEC (USA), branch circuit breakers are often sized at 125% of the continuous load plus 100% of any non-continuous load. “Continuous” means operation for 3 hours or more. Thus, a 20 A continuous load would require a breaker rated for about 25 A (or the next standard size, such as 30 A, since 25 A is not common in NEC standards). This accounts for heat buildup – while a breaker can carry 100% continuously, the code adds a 25% margin for continuous loads to prevent nuisance tripping due to thermal accumulation. Similarly, conductors are sized at 125% for continuous loads, aligning both cable and breaker sizing.

Short-Circuit Rating and Coordination

After ensuring proper overload sizing, the breaker's interrupting rating must be at least equal to the available fault current at its point of installation. For example, a typical residential breaker might have a 10 kA IC. In a home where the service fault current is about 5 kA, that is acceptable. However, in an industrial plant with fault currents of 50 kA, high-rupturing-capacity breakers (often rated at 65 kA or 100 kA) are required. If the fault level exceeds what a single breaker can handle, designers may use a current-limiting fuse or an upstream breaker to reduce the fault seen by downstream devices (this is known as series rating or let-through energy coordination).

Additionally, breakers must be selected for the correct voltage rating. For instance, a breaker used on a 480 V system must be rated for 480 V; using a 240 V-rated device on a 480 V system could lead to arc flashover even if the current remains within range.

Circuit Breaker Types and Applications

  • Motor Circuits: Breakers (or motor circuit protectors) are often sized larger relative to the full-load current (FLC) because motors have high inrush currents (locked-rotor conditions). For example, NEC may allow a motor branch breaker up to 250% of the motor FLC to avoid nuisance tripping during start-up – while separate overload relays protect against sustained overload.
  • Transformers: The primary breaker is often sized at approximately 125% of the rated current (per NEC) to account for high magnetizing inrush currents.
  • Capacitor Banks: Breakers must handle inrush and harmonic currents, sometimes requiring special considerations.
  • Miniature Breakers (MCBs): In buildings, MCBs are typically categorized as B, C, or D curves under BS/EN standards, representing different instantaneous trip thresholds (e.g., B trips at roughly 5×In, while D trips at around 10×In) to accommodate varying inrush loads.

Standards

  • BS 7671 / IET Regulations: These clearly express the overload coordination rule Ib ≤ In ≤ Iz and require that the device's breaking capacity meets the prospective fault current as specified by standards such as BS EN 60898 or IEC 60947-2. They also ensure that the let-through energy does not exceed what the cable can handle.
  • NEC (NFPA 70): Sections 210, 215, and 240 provide sizing rules. NEC 215.3 and 210.20(A) essentially mandate the 125% rule for continuous loads. NEC Article 240 covers overcurrent protection and standard sizes, while NEC 110.9 and 110.10 address interrupting and short-circuit ratings.
  • IEC/EN Standards: IEC 60898-1 (for MCBs up to 125 A) and IEC 60947-2 (for industrial MCCBs/ACBs) define breaker ratings such as In, Icu (ultimate breaking capacity), and Ics (service breaking capacity). When designing per IEC, the breaker’s short-circuit capacity must meet or exceed the fault level, with Annex A of IEC 60947-2 detailing discrimination techniques for selectivity and backup.
  • IEEE Standards: The IEEE C37 series (e.g., C37.13 and C37.16) covers power circuit breakers, detailing ratings like short-circuit current rating and short-time withstand capabilities. IEEE 242 (the Buff Book) offers practical guidance on protection and device selection in industrial systems.

Industry Software Tools

  • Protection Coordination Software: Tools such as ETAP, SKM, and Easypower allow input of all breaker settings and ratings, then check these against calculated fault currents. They can also plot time-current curves to ensure that the larger breaker trips after the smaller one in fault scenarios.
  • Manufacturer Selection Tools: Online selectors from Schneider, ABB, Siemens, etc., allow you to enter system voltage, load current, and fault level, and then suggest an appropriate breaker model with the correct trip unit and interrupting capacity.
  • Short-Circuit Calculators: Some software directly reports “device duty” percentages. For instance, a report might indicate that a breaker sees 90% of its interrupting capacity during a fault, which is acceptable; a value of 150% would be problematic.
  • Manual Methods: For simpler projects, engineers may refer to tables in catalogs that show breaker IC ratings at various voltages and then select a breaker based on a rough fault calculation.

In summary, circuit breaker sizing marries the normal operating current of a circuit with its abnormal fault current conditions. The breaker must carry the load during normal operation while reliably interrupting fault currents. By following code formulas and utilizing available fault data, engineers ensure that In is appropriate and that the breaker's interrupting capacity is adequate—thereby protecting both equipment and personnel from overcurrent conditions.